
The Boston Globe has badly neglected to report the story of accused murderer (and Massachusetts fugitive) Daniel Tavares.
The Boston Herald reporters, on the other hand, seems to have at least assembled a few facts and relevant documents concerning why Tavares was released without bail in Massachusetts and what he was supposed to be doing while under the supervision of the Massachusetts Department of Probation.
The Globe website has 4 Tavares stories today, but 1 is from AP focused on the presidential primary campaign and 2 stories by Globe reporter Brian Mooney also focus on the Giuliani-Romney angle (here and here). The only other Globe report is a zero-content story from an “no comment” interview with judge Tuttman, who set Tavares free on personal recognizance.
No details of the process leading to Tavares’ release have been published in the Globe. One might suspect that the Globe reporters are researching their information by having it spoon-fed to them while riding on New Hampshire campaign buses. They could at least read other newspapers.
The Herald’s reporters, for example, have found and reported on documents and facts concerning the circumstances of Tavares’ release.
Michele McPhee and Jessica Van Sack Saturday November 24:
Tuttman is under fire for releasing Tavares, 41, who had just served 16 years for slashing his mother to death with a carving knife, over the objections of Worcester County prosecutors who warned her of his violent history.
“Not only did he just finish a manslaughter sentence . . . he had a robbery charge and he had an assault charge (before he killed his mother),” Worcester Assistant District Attorney William Loughlin said, according to a transcript of a bail review hearing in front of Tuttman on July 16 after Tavares was charged with assaulting two prison guards.
“So he has a history of crimes of violence, and he committed crimes of violence while he was even serving for a crime of violence,” Loughlin said. “High cash bails are needed.”
But Tuttman chose instead to overrule a District Court judge’s decision to hold Tavares on $50,000 cash bail and she set him free, saying it was unlikely the convicted killer “poses a flight risk.”
Prosecutors also asked Tuttman to put a monitoring bracelet on Tavares, citing his “significant history of violence,” but the judge refused to do that, too, according to the transcript.
“It is the Court’s view that Mr. Tavares has wrapped his sentence on the underlying offense,” Tuttman said from the bench. “He doesn’t have a history of any defaults on the record. And there is no indication . . . that he is a risk of flight, other than the nature and circumstances of the charges.”
Those charges included accusations that Tavares, using a cast on his arm, punched a correction officer and spit on another prison guard while snarling: “I’m going to kill you, (expletive)! I’ll break your (expletive) arms off!”according to court records.
Tuttman ordered that Tavares be put under the supervision of the Department of Probation, which required him to check in with a probation officer three times a week, maintain employment as a welder and live with a sister in Dighton.
Yesterday, probation spokeswoman Coria Holland refused to say if Tavares fulfilled any of his court-ordered obligations. Tavares failed to show up in court on July 23. He moved to Washington to marry his pen pal, Jennifer Freitas, who began writing to the con after answering his personal ad on www.inmate.com.
Tavares confessed to murdering Beverly and Brian Mauck in the newlyweds’ home on Saturday with a .22-caliber gun he wrapped in a towel, according to Washington court records.
Also Michele McPhee Saturday November 24:
Tavares, neighbors said, told a tale about killing his mother during an argument over his daughter being molested. It is unclear if Tavares has a daughter, but he does refer to one in a series of threatening missives, reviewed by the Herald, that he sent to his father from jail.
Michele McPhee and Jessica Van Sack on November 22:
As part of the conditions for his release, he was ordered to report to a probation officer and work at a company called Davon Steel, said Probation Department spokeswoman Coria Holland.
Holland refused to answer if he checked in with the probation office, and no record of Davon Steel could be found last night.
Even Tavares’ court-appointed-attorney, Eugene Lumelsky of Shrewsbury, questioned Tuttman’s decision. He had asked Clinton District Court Judge Martha Brennan for $10,000 after she originally held Tavares on $50,000.
“They shouldn’t have done something like that,” Lumelsky said. “I’ve never seen anything like $50,000 to personal recognizance.”
Herald Columnist Margery Eagan sums up the question well Sunday:
Under terms of his probation, Tavares was required to check in three times per week and live with a sister in Dighton. Obviously, he wasn’t in Dighton. Probation will not say whether he fulfilled its other requirement, though we do know he failed to show up in court barely a week after his release. We do know that failure to show up generally results in a warrant issued. We do know that quite regularly in this huge, dysfunctional system there are thousands of outstanding warrants for criminals who have also failed to show up, but nobody’s looking for them, either.
CORRECTION: I said there was nothing in the Globe about the release of Tavares. Actually next to nothing is correct. Yesterday's Globe had
a story with this:
Tavares was three days away from his release date on his sentence for killing his mother when he appeared before Tuttman on June 11, charged with assaulting correction officers, said his lawyer, Eugene Lumelsky of Lawrence. Prosecutors asked Tuttman to hold the convict on $50,000 bail for each of the two charges, and Lumelsky requested about $5,000 bail, he said. In July, Tuttman released Tavares on his own personal recognizance.
"I'm stumped," Lumelsky said yesterday of Tuttman's decision.
Tavares fled and turned up next in Washington, where he lived with a woman he had met online while behind bars. The Massachusetts State Police suspected that Tavares was in Washington state and warned Romney to be on the lookout for Tavares when he campaigned in Seattle on Monday, Fehrnstrom said. About the same time, Tavares was arrested on charges of killing the Maucks.
Regardless, the Herald has done more and better reporting on this matter than has the Globe, despite (or perhaps because of) the Globe's "above the tabloids" manner.